Short of losing your entire market share due to a sudden disruptive innovation or a major regulatory change that completely invalidates your business model, there is little that can have a more negative impact on your business than commoditization.
Business commoditization refers to when a product or service becomes so standardized and interchangeable with competitors that it is primarily differentiated by price. When a business loses its unique selling points and is being treated like a general commodity in the marketplace, where customers choose based on the cheapest option rather than branded differentiation or specific features, it has been commoditized.
As a result of commoditization, individual products and services become interchangeable, prices are pushed lower, and profit margins are pressured.
Here are some key factors related to commoditization:
- Loss of Differentiation: When a product becomes commoditized, its unique features and benefits are no longer perceived as significantly different from competitors, making it difficult to command price premiums.
- Price Competition: As products become more similar, competition often focuses heavily on price, leading to a ‘race to the bottom’ where companies try to undercut each other to gain market share.
- Impact on Profit Margins: Commoditization can significantly reduce profit margins for businesses as they are forced to lower prices to remain competitive.
This article is part of the Sentinel Solutions local marketing newsletter. You can sign up here to get local marketing thought pieces sent to your inbox each week.
If you are competing in a commoditized market, you’re largely relegated to ruthlessly managing the expense side of your business toward optimizing margins. Focus on emphasizing reductions in production costs and on selling high volumes at a low profit margin toward developing efficiencies via economies of scale is the name of the game.
The good news is that commoditization often happens slowly over time as competitors replicate features and customers prioritize price in their decision making, leading to a gradual decrease in profit margins and market power. Stay closely tuned into the early signs that commoditization might be creeping into your market:
- Increasing price sensitivity among customers.
- A growing focus on price comparisons rather than product features.
- A slowdown in product development and R&D investment.
- A rise in competitor offerings with similar features.
- Low switching costs between providers.
- A perception that products within the market are becoming increasingly interchangeable.
- Increased price-based competition.
Some examples of business categories that became commoditized include:
- Personal Technology: Once innovative features like touchscreens, graphic interfaces, and high-speed processors became standard across most smartphone and computer brands, the market became more price-driven, leading to commoditization.
- Consumer Goods: Basic items like t-shirts, socks, and generic cleaning supplies often become commodities due to high competition and similar product quality across brands.
- Services: Services like simple web hosting can become commoditized when the core features offered by different providers are largely the same.
Locally, the threat of business commoditization could come in the form of a category competitor opening nearby who adopts a me-too product and merchandising strategy.
Brands can become commoditized, too. When brands lose their unique identity and become essentially indistinguishable from competitors in the market, they are relegated to being the cheapest option among similar products. The brand doesn’t carry much equity at that point.
So how do you avoid commoditization?
To avoid commoditization, a business can focus on building a strong brand identity, differentiating its products and services through unique value propositions, fostering customer relationships, continuously innovating, and prioritizing customer experience and loyalty.
Develop a strong value proposition: Clearly articulate the unique benefits and advantages your product or service offers compared to competitors, going beyond basic features.
Focus on customer experience: Prioritize exceptional customer service, personalized interactions, and seamless experiences to build loyalty and differentiate your brand.
Continuous innovation: Regularly introduce new features, functionality, or product lines to stay ahead of the competition and maintain a perception of value.
Brand building: Invest in creating a strong brand identity with a distinct personality, messaging, and visual elements that resonate with your target audience.
Targeted marketing: Target the right customers and tailor your marketing efforts to specific customer segments, highlighting the features most relevant to their specific needs.
Niche specialization: Focus on a specific niche where you can offer deeper expertise and cater to unique customer requirements.
Effective supplementary products and services: Bundle your product with additional value-added products and/or services that are further differentiated and difficult for your competition to replicate. Further, strategic price bundling can help to move buyers to focus less on price comparisons and more on the value of the bundle.
Build customer relationships: Cultivate strong connections with clients through personalized communication, loyalty programs, and proactive engagement.
Price strategically: While price can be a factor, avoid solely competing on price alone. Instead, emphasize the value you deliver and position your price accordingly.
Market research and analysis: Stay informed about competitor activity, market trends, and customer needs to identify opportunities for differentiation.
Invest in expertise: Develop in-depth knowledge and skills within your team to provide exceptional customer service and solutions.
By all means, avoid generic product positioning and price-based competition.
Competing in a commoditized market can be challenging. Key features include minimal product differentiation, intense price sensitivity, a heavy focus on cost-cutting strategies, and a hunt for unique value propositions that resonate with customers. Continuously invest in your business through consumer research, innovation, branding, positioning, and product and pricing strategies that differentiate you from the competition and secure your market share and growth opportunities, and avoid commoditization.
If you’d like to learn more about building unique competitive advantage and building brand relevance into an effective marketing strategy, please give us a call or email us here at Sentinel Solutions.
We are experts in media and can help you build a compelling campaign that engages your audience and drives sales.
Give us a call if we can help at 603-352-5896 or e-mail to Advertising@SentinelDigitalSolutions.com. We’re here to help you succeed.
Additional Resources:
